Skip to main content
gamedev.net
🔒 Locked

solid vs stranded

Started by geekalert Jul 31, 2007 at 11:25 AM 13 replies 3.4k views
Original Post
geekalert
geekalert
I know I've been asking a lot of electronics questions lately on gamedev, but I really dont know where else to turn (usenet is kinda confusing), so please bear with me: Is there any difference between using solid versus stranded wire in building an electromagnet? Like in how strong the electromagnet is? The reason I'm asking is because I wrapped a coil with stranded wire, and it didn't seem to be very strong, or work at all for that matter. Thanks in advance!
A JPEG is worth a thousand and twenty four DWORD's. ;)
Note: Due to vacationing my website will not be updated till late-August. Of course I still have internet, but who wants to program during a vacation?
capn_midnight
capn_midnight
You need a single strand of insulated wire. typically, it's insulated with paint instead of rubber, in order to make the coils tighter. Also, are you using a DC (e.g. battery) or AC power source, because you'll need AC.
benryves
benryves
Quote:
Original post by capn_midnight
Also, are you using a DC (e.g. battery) or AC power source, because you'll need AC.
I believe that's the wrong way around. [grin]
[Website] [+++ Divide By Cucumber Error. Please Reinstall Universe And Reboot +++]
geekalert
geekalert
OK. so I'll need AC power. but before I get an AC-AC transformer, it should be possible to create a galvanometer with DC power right? [disputed]

BTW, why is it that stranded wire does not work? I am not educated on electromagnetic theory, so if somebody explains to me I would appreciate it.

Thanks so far though for the quick reply!
A JPEG is worth a thousand and twenty four DWORD's. ;)
Note: Due to vacationing my website will not be updated till late-August. Of course I still have internet, but who wants to program during a vacation?
benryves
benryves
Quote:
Original post by geekalert
OK. so I'll need AC power. but before I get an AC-AC transformer, it should be possible to create a galvanometer with DC power right? [disputed]
An alternating current will create an alternating magnetic field. I don't think that's what you're after, but I could be wrong.

Quote:
BTW, why is it that stranded wire does not work? I am not educated on electromagnetic theory, so if somebody explains to me I would appreciate it.
I don't think there is anything wrong with stranded wire itself, but typically it's much thicker and so you won't get so much on your coil. The usual wire for the sort of electromagnet I assume you're building is thin, solid-cored and enamel-insulated as you can wind a very tight coil with it (so, basically what capn_midnight said). How many turns are there on your coil?
[Website] [+++ Divide By Cucumber Error. Please Reinstall Universe And Reboot +++]
Promit
Promit
You typically wrap an electromagnet with lots of turns of thin wire, because the number of turns affects the magnet's power. You want it thick enough to handle the current you want to feed it, and no more. 42 gauge magnet wire is a common choice. You can't really strand a wire which is that thin.
SlimDX | Ventspace Blog | Twitter | Diverse teams make better games. I am currently hiring capable C++ engine developers in Baltimore, MD.
Extrarius
Extrarius
Stranded wire doesn't work as well because the magnetic field isn't uniform. The magnetic field is perpendicular to the current. In a solid wire, that means it forms a cylindrical surface away from the wire. In a stranded wire, it'll be a very complicated shape because each of the strands has a magnetic field and they're all pointing slightly different directions and thus not reinforcing eachother as much as they could.

Or so I'd guess, anyways.
"Walk not the trodden path, for it has borne it's burden." -John, Flying Monk
capn_midnight
capn_midnight
Quote:
Original post by benryves
Quote:
Original post by capn_midnight
Also, are you using a DC (e.g. battery) or AC power source, because you'll need AC.
I believe that's the wrong way around. [grin]


...

I thought a magnetic field was created by a change in electrical current, and a DC power source would then only create a magnetic field just as the circuit was closed. There would be current afterwards, but no change in current.

gah, I can't remember.
trzy
trzy
Quote:
Original post by capn_midnight
Quote:
Original post by benryves
Quote:
Original post by capn_midnight
Also, are you using a DC (e.g. battery) or AC power source, because you'll need AC.
I believe that's the wrong way around. [grin]


...

I thought a magnetic field was created by a change in electrical current, and a DC power source would then only create a magnetic field just as the circuit was closed. There would be current afterwards, but no change in current.

gah, I can't remember.


You're thinking of Faraday's Law and electromotive force (voltage.)

----Bart
geekalert
geekalert
i could only fit 14 turns with the length of wire I cut... that's probably really little. I believe I am using 20 or 22 guage wire.
A JPEG is worth a thousand and twenty four DWORD's. ;)
Note: Due to vacationing my website will not be updated till late-August. Of course I still have internet, but who wants to program during a vacation?
Promit
Promit
It's not really a lot, no. An electric guitar pickup, which works backwards but uses the same principle, is typically between 7000 and 9000 turns.
SlimDX | Ventspace Blog | Twitter | Diverse teams make better games. I am currently hiring capable C++ engine developers in Baltimore, MD.
Deleter
Deleter
Quote:
Original post by benryves
Quote:
Original post by geekalert
OK. so I'll need AC power. but before I get an AC-AC transformer, it should be possible to create a galvanometer with DC power right? [disputed]
An alternating current will create an alternating magnetic field. I don't think that's what you're after, but I could be wrong.


And also a changing magnetic flux, which will induce a back emf which will reduce the strength of it...most likely not what you are after.
Programmer One
Programmer One
Quote:
Original post by Extrarius
Stranded wire doesn't work as well because the magnetic field isn't uniform. The magnetic field is perpendicular to the current. In a solid wire, that means it forms a cylindrical surface away from the wire. In a stranded wire, it'll be a very complicated shape because each of the strands has a magnetic field and they're all pointing slightly different directions and thus not reinforcing eachother as much as they could.

Or so I'd guess, anyways.


If that were true, I'd image that the magnetic field would be a whole lot denser than that of a solid wire. Perhaps if the strands are twisted it might make a difference...?

Example:
Extrarius
Extrarius
Quote:
Original post by Programmer One
[...]If that were true, I'd image that the magnetic field would be a whole lot denser than that of a solid wire.[...]
The same amount of current is flowing through the same amount of space, but instead of one strong field you have many weak ones facing slightly different directions. Because the strength is inversely proportional to distance squared, a few strong fields add better than many small ones.
Quote:
[...]Perhaps if the strands are twisted it might make a difference...?[...]
I've never seen a stranded wire that wasn't braided, twisted, or otherwise 'tangled' inside the insulation.
"Walk not the trodden path, for it has borne it's burden." -John, Flying Monk
RSC_x
RSC_x
you need more voltage and thin cables.
turn it like 20 times and use 9(+-6) volt.dc
and thinny isolated cables which is possible.
and may be a needle for test it.
more voltage allways makes it strong.
but if you use 220~ volt. this may fire.or rip?
generally 220(standard voltage) did not kill me but i cant prove.
it is also about currency power (a).
ac is using on dynamic systems (i think)
ac will not work on statik magnets (or you can't see) like your's.
© Loading...<font col

Topic Locked

This topic has been locked by a moderator. New replies are not allowed.

Sign in to reply to this topic.