Mobigame's Edge pulled because of the word Edge

Jerrick clarington · 2009-08-12T08:02:45

I'm just quoting this from another forum, this is ridiculous for indie gamers. Quote: Throwing this in indie games to help support a fellow indie developer in Mobigame. A few weeks ago, Mobigame's game Edge was pulled from the App Store for unknown reasons. Well, now we know why. It looks like one Tim Langdell believes he owns a monopoly on the word EDGE and is doing his best to be a dick. http://fingergaming.com/2009/05/28/update-edge-pulled-over-alledged-trademark-infringement/ Quote: Langdell, CEO of EDGE Games, GDC 2009 speaker and Lead Game Faculty at National University, contacted Mobigame and Apple in April asking that the game be pulled. Langdell claims his company owns the worldwide “trademark” EDGE. Despite this, the game remains up in other territories. This is not the first time. Simon Carless wrote a pretty scathing article on Tim Langdell and his trademark on the word EDGE before it got pulled for unknown reasons. Luckily the article's been copied and posted in other places. http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=16044280&postcount=5953 Quote: It looks like trademark suits based around the word 'EDGE' and anything game-related are still occurring, too, too - here's one from March 2009 against Cybernet, who are making an obscure, long-dormant game called Edge of Extinction. According to the suit, brought by Cybernet, Langdell started writing to them in January 2009, demanding that the 'Edge Of Extinction' trademark be assigned to him for free and that a license agreement be signed with Edge Games. When Cybernet refused, and asked for money for the domain transfer, Langdell said to "expect... [a] Federal Law Suit", so Cybernet sued Langdell and Edge. The case appears to be ongoing. And there's some evidence, via a Virginia-based website's PDF, of a series of similar discussions with computer manufacturer Velocity for their 'Velocity Edge' gaming PCs. In this particular document, which is based around a suit by Velocity, the Court finds Edge Interactive liable for several falsehoods related to the suit, including untrue claims that Langdell had resigned from the company and could not receive the countersuit. Overall, the Virginia District Court found a "deliberate strategy [on the part of Edge Interactive] to obfuscate and mislead this Court in order to delay the Court's determination of default." (However, the companies settled confidentially in December 2008 and Langdell now lists 'EDGE game PCs (made by Velocity Micro)' as an 'EDGE branded venture' that he has 'spawned'.) [snip snip...] But now we're seeing great indie developers like Edge creator Mobigame hobbled because Langdell is aggressively enforcing his trademark based purely on a four letter name - rather than a particular style of game or character similarities, if that is even a more justifiable reason to do so. I think that's a major shame and, at least from my personal point of view, a morally repugnant thing to do. Even if Tim Langdell and Mobigame somehow come to an agreement to get Edge back on the App Store, I hope this story can spread far enough so the negative publicity for these EDGE legal cases becomes an issue for one Mr. Tim Langdell. Note how Tim Langdell for the most part has had nothing to do with the vast majority of projected with the name EDGE in them. He's a vulture. He swoops in for his licensing fee and bullies around people who can't afford fancy lawyers. The story just broke last night so hopefully more details will be forthcoming. please continue to post this story anywhere.

GDNet Lounge Community

Started by Bearrick92 August 03, 2009 12:57 PM

56 comments, last by Wan 15 years, 3 months ago

ViLiO

1,326

August 04, 2009 08:05 AM

I am going to make a game called "Strumming with The Edge" starring The REAL Edge [cool]

Langdell won't stand a chance in the courtroom [grin]

Richard 'ViLiO' Thomasv.net | Twitter | YouTube

Mithrandir

607

August 04, 2009 11:13 AM

Quote: Original post by JimboC
I can understand trademarks and see the need for them. I think they went overboard in protecting their trademark in this case, but that's what corporations do.

Actually they didn't have a choice. If a company doesn't defend its trademark, then they lose it. It's just how the law works.

This is my signature. There are many like it, but this one is mine. My signature is my best friend. It is my life. I must master it as I must master my life. My signature, without me, is useless. Without my signature, I am useless.

d000hg

1,208

August 04, 2009 11:25 AM

I'm sure there must be literally hundreds of companies with the word "edge" in their name, since it's a fairly nice-sounding word. Edge Computers, Edge Recruitment, etc.

There's even video-game related magazine called "Edge", how have all these companies survived?!

Sneftel

1,788

August 04, 2009 11:47 AM

Quote: Original post by Daerax
Is Apple really so whimsical about what apps it accepts into its store and so trigger happy in pulling them?

Well, look at it from their point of view. It's not their fight. They're going to make fuckall revenue off "Edge" regardless. The last thing they want is to be named as a defendant in someone else's trademark lawsuit, no matter how frivolous they think it is.

Maverick Programmer

100

August 04, 2009 11:55 AM

How did the game "Mirror's Edge" get away with it then?

Holy crap, you can read!

Steadtler

220

August 04, 2009 12:10 PM

Quote: Original post by Maverick Programmer
How did the game "Mirror's Edge" get away with it then?

I guess he didnt dare to try his case against EA's lawyers. Its easier to bully small developpers, and if he lost against EA that would have been a precedent for others to defend against him.

Kaze

948

August 04, 2009 12:46 PM

wow, he has way too much time on his hands

slayemin

6,313

August 04, 2009 02:15 PM

Wow, I didn't know words themselves could be trademarked! I MUST trademark the words "the", "and", "is", and "a". Anyone caught using those words must either pay a royalty to me or cease and desist!

"The Passion of the christ" infringes on my trademarked words TWICE!! Mel Gibson had better pay up!

Eric Nevala

Indie Developer | Spellbound | Dev blog | Twitter | Unreal Engine 4

evolutional

1,397

August 04, 2009 04:43 PM

I find actions such as these, whether legal or not, are disgraceful for someone who's supposed to be helping the very people he's cutting down.

Is it true that the developer of "Edge" offered to rename the game "Edgy" and Langdell then trademarked "Edgy" to stop them?