Skip to main content
GameDev.net gamedev.net
🔒 Locked

Minority groups in europe

Started by dpadam450 Feb 18, 2011 at 12:25 AM 18 replies 3.8k views
Original Post
dpadam450
dpadam450
We ended up talking about amish people for a minute and now I'm curious. Do people in european countries have groups like amish, scientologist and mormons? Thats just a few off the top of my head but I assume nobody in the middle east would ever see a picture of an amish family and think that they were american. Just wondering if you guys know what those groups are and/or if you have your own groups as well.
NBA2K, Madden, Maneater, Killing Floor, Sims 
karwosts
karwosts
Mormons and Scientologist both exist in Europe as well.

For minority groups the Roma/Gypsies come to mind.
[size=2]My Projects:
[size=2]Portfolio Map for Android - Free Visual Portfolio Tracker
[size=2]Electron Flux for Android - Free Puzzle/Logic Game
Hodgman
Hodgman
There's scientologists and mormons in Australia too -- those cults seem pretty global these days.

There's plenty of ethnic minorities in Australia with 1 in 5 people having been born overseas (or 1 in 3 people in my city). The indigenous population (Australian aborigines) are actually a pretty small minority, making up about 1 in 50 people.
Some of the ethnic groupings here probably wouldn't be recognised by Americans/Europeans (i.e. non-pacific people) - e.g. Micronesians, Polynesians, Melanesians.
Zeraan
Zeraan

There's scientologists and mormons in Australia too -- those cults seem pretty global these days.

There's plenty of ethnic minorities in Australia with 1 in 5 people having been born overseas (or 1 in 3 people in my city). The indigenous population (Australian aborigines) are actually a pretty small minority, making up about 1 in 50 people.
Some of the ethnic groupings here probably wouldn't be recognised by Americans/Europeans (i.e. non-pacific people) - e.g. Micronesians, Polynesians, Melanesians.



Mormons is a cult? How so?
Hodgman
Hodgman

Mormons is a cult? How so?
I think I saw a post elsewhere that said you followed the latter day saints, so I'm sorry if this is offensive. There's no such thing as the absolute truth, and we're all entitled to believe in our own version of the truth...
...however, in my truth, the Mormon prophet was a known criminal, fraud, medium, charlatan, etc... who founded a fake religion with the purpose of obtaining fame, wealth and polygamist sex for himself. I personally regard such self-serving religious inventions as cults. That's the way I interpret the facts. You're free to interpret them as the acts of a prophet though.
Prune
Prune

For minority groups the Roma/Gypsies come to mind.

This reminds me of a classic Wizard of Id cartoon from the funny papers, where someone tells the monarch that he sees a band of gypsies coming. The latter says "quick, raise the drawbridge!", but it's too late as the other says "what drawbridge?" (implying the gypsies even stole the drawbridge).

As someone from Eastern Europe, where there's heavy gypsy infestation, I can only confirm how apt this cartoon is. Thievery and other petty crime is rampant among the gypsy population. While I wouldn't say the origin is genetic, quite clearly it is a fundamental, if uncodified, aspect of their culture. It has little to do with their economic conditions, as these are largely self-inflicted. During the past when my country of origin was still under communist rule, they were afforded the same opportunities (and restrictions of course) as every other member of the proletariat, yet they still stood out with their degenerate social behavior and complete and pure lack of any moral and ethical substance.

The ameliorating circumstances regarding the gypsies are that they are not well organized and lack drive and ambition, which tempers their potential for destructive influence to Western civilization. This makes them purely a nuisance (and you see France etc. deal with them in such a manner), as opposed to the the West's existential threats of widespread and increasingly empowered Islamic fundamentalism, and the amoral and repressive but efficient Chinese state capitalism.
"But who prays for Satan? Who, in eighteen centuries, has had the common humanity to pray for the one sinner that needed it most?" --Mark Twain

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Looking for a high-performance, easy to use, and lightweight math library? http://www.cmldev.net/ (note: I'm not associated with that project; just a user)
IADaveMark
IADaveMark

...however, in my truth, the Mormon prophet was a known criminal, fraud, medium, charlatan, etc... who founded a fake religion with the purpose of obtaining fame, wealth and polygamist sex for himself. I personally regard such self-serving religious inventions as cults. That's the way I interpret the facts. You're free to interpret them as the acts of a prophet though.

I am amused by this. You know nothing of the religion.


Dave Mark - President and Lead Designer of Intrinsic Algorithm LLC
Professional consultant on game AI, mathematical modeling, simulation modeling
Co-founder and 10 year advisor of the GDC AI Summit<
Zeraan
Zeraan

[quote name='Zeraan' timestamp='1298006687' post='4775713']
Mormons is a cult? How so?
I think I saw a post elsewhere that said you followed the latter day saints, so I'm sorry if this is offensive. There's no such thing as the absolute truth, and we're all entitled to believe in our own version of the truth...
...however, in my truth, the Mormon prophet was a known criminal, fraud, medium, charlatan, etc... who founded a fake religion with the purpose of obtaining fame, wealth and polygamist sex for himself. I personally regard such self-serving religious inventions as cults. That's the way I interpret the facts. You're free to interpret them as the acts of a prophet though.
[/quote]

I can understand why you'd think it's a cult based on that article. But it is biased against Mormons, you'd need to consider both sides to give it a fair opinion. One example, Joseph did show the golden plates to 11 other people, that article implied that he never showed it to anyone.

Don't worry, I'm not offended, I'm just weary of people bashing Mormons as a cult full of mysterious occults and secrets. Most people that I've met that are anti-Mormon have only read articles that are biased against Mormons, and don't know what our actual beliefs are. A friend even had a person ask him if he had horns growing on his head.
dpadam450
dpadam450
I can consider Catholics to be a cult full of pedophiles and cannibals (eating literal flesh and blood of Jesus through transmutation or whatever) who believe in a bisexual God (Priests and nuns are married to Jesus), but that's one biased view, and not fair to Catholics.[/quote]
Well I think most people know that a small minority of priests have done this, so to say 'full of pedophiles' is weird. Just because some priests' have done it doesnt mean catholics believe it. Just because a few muslims are suicide bombers doesnt mean they all are. His argument is what mormans actually believe and how the religion was founded. All religions have their extreme wackjobs (like that one church that protests military funerals). On a side note I think all child molesters should be put away for life, but whats sad is that if a priest does it everyone goes nuts, but when michael jackson did it, we buy his tickets and praise his funeral. People just WANT to hate other religions, they just need a reason. All I know about mormons is what a south park episode told me and that was hilarious.
NBA2K, Madden, Maneater, Killing Floor, Sims 
Zeraan
Zeraan

I can consider Catholics to be a cult full of pedophiles and cannibals (eating literal flesh and blood of Jesus through transmutation or whatever) who believe in a bisexual God (Priests and nuns are married to Jesus), but that's one biased view, and not fair to Catholics.

Well I think most people know that a small minority of priests have done this, so to say 'full of pedophiles' is weird. Just because some priests' have done it doesnt mean catholics believe it. Just because a few muslims are suicide bombers doesnt mean they all are. His argument is what mormans actually believe and how the religion was founded. All religions have their extreme wackjobs (like that one church that protests military funerals). On a side note I think all child molesters should be put away for life, but whats sad is that if a priest does it everyone goes nuts, but when michael jackson did it, we buy his tickets and praise his funeral. People just WANT to hate other religions, they just need a reason. All I know about mormons is what a south park episode told me and that was hilarious.
[/quote]

Well, that's what happens when you "twist" something in what it's not. I edited out the Catholic part a few moments after I posted it, because I felt that it wasn't appropriate and can be insulting to Catholics. But the point is, people see flaws, or sometimes see things that are not there, and blow it all out of proportion.

You focused on "full of pedophiles", while disregarding the rest of the statement, I said that view is not fair because not all catholics are pedophiles (a very few, maybe hundreds out of a billion people?). But people can twist the news to suit their view, and that was what I was trying to point out. I wasn't trying to insult the Catholics, I respect their beliefs and the people.

Hodgman's arguments are not what the Mormons believe. I've studied Joseph Smith's history (both sides of view), while he do have his flaws, he wasn't what Hodgman described him as.

Heh, that south park episode, I've heard about it, but never seen it. I should watch it sometime smile.gif
mikeman
mikeman

Heh, that south park episode, I've heard about it, but never seen it. I should watch it sometime smile.gif


Keep in mind, Parker and Stone seem to love Mormons. In one particular episode, where bunch of people are going to Hell and Heaven, an angel is speaking to the crowds and saying 'and if you're you're wondering who gets into heaven, the correct answer is...the mormons, yes the mormons".


Khaiy
Khaiy
The line between cult and religion is pretty blurry, and if you think that a mainstream religion (perhaps yours, perhaps not) is significantly different from what people widely agree are cults (in the Heaven's Gate sense), I would like to hear your reasoning as to why. I want to be clear that I'm not trying to be hostile, but that I usually don't hear much argumentation about this, and am interested in the views of people who follow a religion regarding the distinction.

As for Mormonism, in my view it's not on any shakier ground than any other religion as far as beliefs go, but there are curious events that pique the doubts in people who want to do so. I remember a scammer (I forget his name) who forged artifacts that contradicted the Joseph Smith story, because he believed that the church leaders would buy them from him to keep them away from people who might use them to discredit claims about the church's origin. It worked, and he made a lot of money until he was eventually caught by police.

On the other hand, I came across an interesting essay a while back by Orson Scott Card (back when he could still write well, no less) that looked at the scale and complexity of fraud that would be needed to fake the Joseph Smith story. You can read it here.
     -------R.I.P.-------      Selective Quote ~Too Late - Too Soon~
dpadam450
dpadam450
That and they have a broadway show about mormons.... they said mormons have an interesting story, but they rip on religions all the time.
NBA2K, Madden, Maneater, Killing Floor, Sims 
Fl4sh
Fl4sh

[quote name='Hodgman' timestamp='1297994192' post='4775662']
There's scientologists and mormons in Australia too -- those cults seem pretty global these days.

There's plenty of ethnic minorities in Australia with 1 in 5 people having been born overseas (or 1 in 3 people in my city). The indigenous population (Australian aborigines) are actually a pretty small minority, making up about 1 in 50 people.
Some of the ethnic groupings here probably wouldn't be recognised by Americans/Europeans (i.e. non-pacific people) - e.g. Micronesians, Polynesians, Melanesians.



Mormons is a cult? How so?
[/quote]

Well I knew a guy who said Jesus was coming back to establish his kingdom in Utah or some crap..he was from a sect of mormons.
They hated on Jeezus, so you think I give a f***?!
Moe
Moe

[quote name='Zeraan' timestamp='1298006687' post='4775713']
[quote name='Hodgman' timestamp='1297994192' post='4775662']
There's scientologists and mormons in Australia too -- those cults seem pretty global these days.

There's plenty of ethnic minorities in Australia with 1 in 5 people having been born overseas (or 1 in 3 people in my city). The indigenous population (Australian aborigines) are actually a pretty small minority, making up about 1 in 50 people.
Some of the ethnic groupings here probably wouldn't be recognised by Americans/Europeans (i.e. non-pacific people) - e.g. Micronesians, Polynesians, Melanesians.



Mormons is a cult? How so?
[/quote]

Well I knew a guy who said Jesus was coming back to establish his kingdom in Utah or some crap..he was from a sect of mormons.
[/quote]
Is there supposed to be a sarcasm tag on that or not?

To answer the OP: Yes, Europe as groups of minorities as well. Thinking about it, probably more so - you have lots of small countries, a decent number of dialects, and a fair bit of shuffling around. They may not be as visible as other minority groups, but they are there.

To the other posters: I'm a Mormon, and I find your discussion quite entertaining. When I think of a cult in the traditional sense, I don't generally think of a group of 12+ million. I do appreciate your discussions of both sides, but how about next time we try to keep it on topic, OK?


dpadam450
dpadam450
Is there anything like amish people in europe? Its beyond me why people would drive a horse and not believe in the cars that drive by them all the time.
NBA2K, Madden, Maneater, Killing Floor, Sims 
Zeraan
Zeraan

Is there anything like amish people in europe? Its beyond me why people would drive a horse and not believe in the cars that drive by them all the time.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amish

Looks like they originated in Switzerland, so I guess it's possible that some of them live in Europe still. It seems that most of them migrated to USA or Canada.
Khaiy
Khaiy

Is there anything like amish people in europe? Its beyond me why people would drive a horse and not believe in the cars that drive by them all the time.


I think it's not so much that they don't believe in cars (I'm assuming that you're using "believe in" in the sense of people thinking that they exist, as in ghosts), but rather that they reject them as being unacceptable in some fundamental way. Why exactly they feel the need to cling to that old lifestyle is beyond me as well.
     -------R.I.P.-------      Selective Quote ~Too Late - Too Soon~
samoth
samoth

[quote name='Hodgman' timestamp='1298007859' post='4775721']...

I am amused by this. You know nothing of the religion.
[/quote]Luckily, this is only a minor problem that can be solved easily: Documentary.

Topic Locked

This topic has been locked by a moderator. New replies are not allowed.

Sign in to reply to this topic.