Skip to main content
GameDev.net gamedev.net

PRO Tired of ads? Read GameDev.net ad-free and help keep the community independent with GameDev Pro — $3/month.

Unity was Overrated

Unity was Overrated

hagerprof
hagerprof
Master of None · · 2 min read
5,033 -1

With the recent changes of Unity pricing and billing, it appears that the number of users will go down … immensely. To be honest, I’m kind of glad. I’m not glad in a glee-filled way. I don’t like seeing things fail. I just was never a Unity guy.

When Unity started off, it seemed to have this unnatural buzz around it. I was unsure why everyone migrated so quickly to it. For what? It took years for the first AAA studio to use it for an actual product. Up until then, it produced things that mostly looked like advanced student projects.

If you look a Godot now, it is more advanced than Unity was on its 9th birthday. Granted technology has advanced, but it is not like Godot is going to be ordained Prince (behind Unreal) like Unity was around that time.

On the topic of Godot, if you are looking for a place to escape from Unity, look there. That’s not a plug for Godot. They just design a game in similar fashion. To be honest, I don’t like the way either has you construct a game. I call it the Apple principal. If you think like a Mac, it feels totally intuitive. If you don’t, it can be frustrating.

I am not talking from personal experience, but as a Professor who taught Unity. Students were often flustered. Like Unreal, you spend a lot of time understanding the engine in order to make it work correctly. So much so, that it takes a long time to make something worthwhile. People jumped on the Unity bandwagon too early and maybe too vigorously. In the end, we created a monster in which many feel addicted.

Now, as Unity squeezes creators away from it, it will be hard for many to make the leap to other engines … at first. After all, Unity had some things going for it. Two of the best of which were: 1) It was free to try to make games, and 2) It had a great asset store. Even though, I won’t miss being pushed to use or teach Unity, the end product did bear fruit. Hopefully, future game engine developers will take note. It’s time to de-seat the prince.


If you like to try out one of my free apps (for copying and moving bulk files,) please go here:

https://apps.microsoft.com/store/detail/filesnatch-free/9NTT08T64GLF

If you’d like to pay me $2.79 for roughly the same app without ads, please go here:

https://apps.microsoft.com/store/detail/filesnatch/9P6WGSGHCN67

If you like to see me post silly things from my company, try this:

https://www.facebook.com/people/Digital-Tumult/100057555664875/

If you’d like to see me in action:

https://www.youtube.com/@digitaltumult

Recommended resources

Game Engines

See full guide
Unreal Engine 5 Best Practices cover
Editor pick

Unreal Engine 5 Best Practices

Amazon · Book

Written by multi-award-winning Unreal generalist Tyson J. Butler-Boschma, Founder and Creative Director of Toybox Games Studios, this book addresses common challenges you face when advancing your expertise in lighting, environment design, and cinematic storytelling.

GameDev.net may earn a commission if you purchase through these links. This helps fund the site at no extra cost to you.

GameDev.net may earn a commission if you purchase through these links. This helps fund the site at no extra cost to you.

Discussion

Loading comments...